A Systematic Categorization of Performance Measures for Estimated Non-Linear Associations Between an Outcome and Continuous Predictors

In regression analysis, associations between continuous predictors and the outcome are often assumed to be linear. However, modeling the associations as non-linear can improve model fit. Many flexible modeling techniques, like (fractional) polynomials and spline-based approaches, are available. Such methods can be systematically compared in simulation studies, which require suitable performance measures to evaluate the accuracy of the estimated curves against the true data-generating functions. Although various measures have been proposed in the literature, no systematic overview exists so far. To fill this gap, we introduce a categorization of performance measures for evaluating estimated non-linear associations between an outcome and continuous predictors. This categorization includes many commonly used measures. The measures can not only be used in simulation studies, but also in application studies to compare different estimates to each other. We further illustrate and compare the behavior of different performance measures through some examples and a Shiny app. This article is categorized under: Statistical and Graphical Methods of Data Analysis > Modeling Methods and Algorithms.